USERNAME PASSWORD
  Forgot Username?   Forgot Password?  Sign Up
 
Click to List Latest Articles

Tendulkar vs Ponting , who is better ? -By Harsh Mittal

They may be regarded as 2 of the finest batsmen of modern era , but sach's far ahead For the last 10 years or so, there has never been a debate as to who the best ODI batsman is. Such has been the domination of one man, Sachin Ramesh Tendulkar, that no one has ever questioned his emperor status in ODI cricket. Having amassed 15,000 runs in the game with 41 hundreds, he is well ahead of the rest. It would probably take Ricky Ponting another ODI career to get even close to Tendulkar in ODI cricket as a gap of 18 centuries between the two players illustrates! Unless statistics are twisted, which is often the case when it comes to modern day media, they tend to indicate the truth. Given below are the records of both players in ODI cricket :

 

Performance in ODI cricket

 

Batsman

Matches

Runs

Batting Average

Highest Score

100s

50s

S. Tendulkar

388

15051

44.13

186*

41

79

R. Ponting

288

10395

43.31

164

23

62

 

Sachin is the undisputed leader with respect to overall career records. However, all critics always tend to say that Tendulkar doesn't perform well in pressure situations whereas Ponting does. Lets look at the stats for all such games :

 

Performance in matches where team won chasing a target (ODI)

 

Batsman

Matches

Runs

Batting Average

Highest Score

100s

50s

S. Tendulkar

101

4397

58.62

134

13

23

R. Ponting

77

2670

53.40

124*

4

17

 

Performance in Quarter Finals (ODI)

 

Batsman

Matches

Runs

Batting Average

Highest Score

100s

50s

S. Tendulkar

3

210

70.0

141

1

0

R. Ponting

3

118

39.33

46

0

0

 

Performance in Semi Finals (ODI)

 

Batsman

Matches

Runs

Batting Average

Highest Score

100s

50s

S. Tendulkar

7

232

33.14

83

0

2

R. Ponting

5

71

14.20

37

0

0

 

Performance in Finals (ODI)

 

Batsman

Matches

Runs

Batting Average

Highest Score

100s

50s

S. Tendulkar

36

1487

47.96

134

4

9

R. Ponting

33

1217

45.07

140*

2

6

 

Performance in Series Won (ODI)

 

Batsman

Matches

Runs

Batting Average

Highest Score

100s

50s

S. Tendulkar

127

5548

51.37

186*

19

26

R. Ponting

177

7245

47.98

145

18

45

 

Some might say that Tendulkar has played for a very long time so his records are bound to be phenomenal. If that's the case, then why isn't Inzamam Ul Haq's record anywhere close to Tendulkar's? Inzamam has been playing since 1991 and has played 378 matches and is still more than 3000 runs behind the little master. The stats above just illustrate the complete dominance of ODI batting by Tendulkar and I'm sure with the nullification of the argument of him not performing in pressure situations, the critics wouldn't have much to say.

 

The real debate, however, in the last few years has been about Test Cricket. Everyone has been going gaga about Ponting's performances in the test arena and they are not wrong in doing so as he has scored 10 hundreds in the last one year or so. So is he a better test batsman than Tendulkar? On current form Ponting might have the edge. But overall, the scales definitely tilt towards Sachin. Here are some very interesting stats to back up my assertion.

 

Performance in India (Tests)

 

Batsman

Matches

Runs

Batting Average

Highest Score

100s

50s

S. Tendulkar

60

4917

55.24

217

16

19

R. Ponting

8

172

12.28

60

0

1

 

Performance in Australia (Tests)

 

Batsman

Matches

Runs

Batting Average

Highest Score

100s

50s

S. Tendulkar

12

1029

54.15

241*

4

3

R. Ponting

62

5483

64.50

257

18

24

 

In their respective home countries, both batsman are prolific scorers averaging over 55 runs per innings. However, Tendulkar averages 54 even in Australia which is a feat in itself for any batsman in the world. The shocking bit is, and all Ponting supporters should brace themselves because this one is going to sting, Ponting averages 12.28 in India in test cricket! He has never even scored a century on Indian soil whereas Tendulkar scored two hundreds on his very first tour to Australia. The best spinner of all time - Shane Warne himself conceded that he had nightmares of Sachin smashing him into the stands. Muralitharan has been one of the premier spinners in the game for some time now and in all tests played against Sri Lanka in their backyard, Ponting averages a brilliant 54.45. Tendulkar, on the other hand averages a mind blowing 111.66. It is, therefore, safe to say that Tendulkar is by far the better player of spin bowling between the two.

Performance in Sri Lanka (Tests)

 

Batsman

Matches

Runs

Batting Average

Highest Score

100s

50s

S. Tendulkar

6

670

111.66

143

4

2

R. Ponting

7

599

54.45

141

2

3

Having already looked at Australia, let us now also consider the performances of the two players in England - the home of swing bowling. Here too Tendulkar leads the race by a big margin.

 

Performance in England (Tests)

 

Batsman

Matches

Runs

Batting Average

Highest Score

100s

50s

S. Tendulkar

10

1074

71.60

193

4

4

R. Ponting

13

938

42.63

156

3

3

 

Finally the best yardstick for a batsman is his performances in away matches. In that regard too, Sachin is one up on Ponting as the table below indicates.

 

Performance in Away Matches (Tests)

 

Batsman

Matches

Runs

Batting Average

Highest Score

100s

50s

S. Tendulkar

77

6005

55.60

248*

21

24

R. Ponting

45

3543

51.34

206

13

12

 

 

The stats obviously prove who the best is and it's the Indian champ, who as always, is on top yet again. Putting the stats aside for a moment however, lets think objectively - Tendulkar faced the likes of Wasim Akram, Waqar Younis, Allan Donald, Curtly Ambrose, Courtney Walsh and Shane Warne when they were at the peak of their careers and scored big runs against them. These are the finest bowlers of all time and include the best spinner (Warne) and the best left arm fast bowler (Akram) that the world has ever seen. He also faced Imran Khan, Craig Mcdermott, Devon Malcom, Glenn Mcgrath and Brett Lee. Ponting has had very little exposure to these guys. He has struggled against Vaas and Harbhajan and judging by that it is safe to say that he wouldn't have prospered against Wasim and Warne. Ponting undoubtedly is an exceptional player and probably one of the best players of the pull shot who has ever played the game but he is no Tendulkar!

 

It's a classic case of Indians not acknowledging that we have the best batsman in the world playing for us in Sachin Ramesh Tendulkar and we'll probably only realise his worth once his magic has disappeared forever after his retirement just like the way we realised the worth of the Kohinoor only after it had been snatched away from us!

 

(All stats can be verified from www.cricinfo.com)

ps. stats till july 2007 .

   
harshad phadke
Posted on: 2010-04-29 12:13:10
Rank: Newbie
Total Topics: 0
Total Comments: 2
Location: Please Update
only a fool can compare ponting wid "THE GREAT SACHIN"compare them at ur own peril!!!!!!I pity those who make such foolish comparisons coz wen v talk abt ponting v r talking abt just other human bt wen v talk abt sachin v talk abt "THE GOD"
 
Kapil Uppal
Posted on: 2010-03-29 06:23:41
Rank: Newbie
Total Topics: 0
Total Comments: 1
Location: Mumbai

People who had compared 'The God of Cricket' i.e the Master itself 'Sachin Tendulkar' to Ricky Ponting has commited the biggest sin his his life.Cool.

 
seshu
Posted on: 2010-03-04 07:34:52
Rank: Newbie
Total Topics: 0
Total Comments: 1
Location: Please Update

Hello friends ,this is seshu.

I have joined in this site recently.

i have seen this poll and very next moment  i get big laugh.

how we can compare THE MASTeR with others.this is very wrong thing.  

even though ponting getting closer  to sachin in test centuries,he cannot become SACHIN RAMESH TENDULKAR.I THINK SACHIN IS THE LIVING LEGEND.HE IS GREAT NOT ONLY IN CRICKET BUT ALSO IN REAL LIFE.

so please do not compare any one with sachin(MASTER BLASTER).

i think he is deserving candidate for BHARATA RATNA.I THINK HE WILL GET in short span of time.

 

 
vasu
Posted on: 2010-02-12 04:56:38
Rank: Newbie
Total Topics: 0
Total Comments: 4
Location: Please Update
of course tendulkar.. ponting is nt even cls 2 him yar
 
vibhav
Posted on: 2010-01-27 14:08:13
Rank: Newbie
Total Topics: 0
Total Comments: 3
Location: Please Update
if cricket is a religion, SACHIN IS THE GOD and ponting is a fraud......
 
Satadru Roy
Posted on: 2009-12-13 12:49:01
Rank: Regular Fan
Total Topics: 18
Total Comments: 72
Location: Kolkata

Don't think Ponting can break the record of Sachin. Please don't get me wrong, but I don't see a chance at all.

Let me make it clear. More than often you have seen, great innings are always made as a part of some good partnerships. However, in earlier times Sachin scored a few hundreds without caring much about incompetencies of fellow players, but that is not the case happening ever in Australia.

Ponting scored the bulk of his runs when the big Matthew Hayden & resolute Justin Langer was reigning supreme at their Opening & most often produced not only big partnerships, but also demoralizing the hapless bowlers by simultaneous Attack & Defense, in their process. Then after they are out, Ponting used to come and make a mincemeat of the tiring bowling attack. Ponting could afford to play freely majorly due to having an assurance that, either Hayden, Langer, Steve Waugh, Martyn, even Hussey can give him company & he need not worry about Runs scored or wickets falling. Even in worst case, if none of the mentioned players click, in comes Adam Gilchrist, undoubtedly one of the most devastating player in the modern cricket & shoots the Run Rate up to 4 & above. Hell, even Warne & Gillespie could bat out the whole day and assure company at the creaze.

But, now the situation is not the same any more. Hayden, Langer, Steve Waugh, Martyn, Warne, Gillespie, Gilchrist has all retired. The team is not the same anymore. Hussey is consistent, but he is going to finish very soon. Clarke is a completely overhyped player. So, now Ponting is more or less out of company.

You just check how many centuries did Ponting score after their famous Openers retired. Ponting always thrived upon their Openers' conquests. He is a good player, but he is never an all-condition player. It was the good partnerships that nourished his scoring.

Since that golden generation is no more, I don't see Ponting scoring much these days. In fact that Carbon-fibre illegal bat is banned which he used to hit those big sixes effortlessly even with mistimed slog shots.

All in while, the story for Sachin was not the same. He scored even before Dravid, Laxman, Ganguly was there, he scored with them with equal ease. He scored with Sehwag, Gambhir, Yuvraj, Dhoni. He scored with Azhar, Jadeja, Vengsarkar, Sidhu, Shastri. He scored in the worst of the Spinning tracks, he scored in the fastest & the bounciest tracks and obviously scored in those batting paradises.  

He both assumed the role of One-Man-Army & also playing second fiddle to the brilliant Laxman in Australia.

That concludes our point. Ponting has never been this much versatile, hence I don't see him Catching up with the God of Cricket in Tests (forget ODIs). The only place I see Ponting surpassing Sachin is in International Twenty20s, since Sachin has decided to stay out of it.

So, I would suggest all my fellow believers in Sachinism, just don't be anxious (even if your heart cries in anguish), no one can touch Sachin records under any circumstances.

 
dibyendu das
Posted on: 2009-11-15 00:02:22
Rank: Newbie
Total Topics: 0
Total Comments: 2
Location: Silchar
Fantastic arcitle. This article should be posted by register to all those critics who says Sach can't perform in final, in a cruch match, when batting in cheasing etc. etc. My heartiest thanks to the writer of the article.
 
Ashish Kaushik
Posted on: 2009-11-14 02:00:03
Rank: Newbie
Total Topics: 0
Total Comments: 1
Location: Please Update

Sachin is Undoubtedly the best..... & hey guys saying the little master just Sachin would be an insult to the Maestro...........

We should start calling him "SIR" SAchin Tendulkar.......

 
Duttnath
Posted on: 2009-11-07 10:59:47
Rank: Tendulkarized
Total Topics: 11
Total Comments: 346
Location: Durg, Chhattisgarh
No doubt that Sach is the best. Saying Ponting "Piggy Ponting" will be an insult to piggies.
 
√arun
Posted on: 2009-11-06 09:45:52
Rank: Absolute Sachinist
Total Topics: 82
Total Comments: 2049
Location: Chandigarh

Now no need to comment anymore after yesterday’s innings, Sachin is way better than Punter, infact no comparison, its just that Sachins Geniuses is covered with the Indian lower order

 
amish
Posted on: 2009-10-27 10:07:07
Rank: Newbie
Total Topics: 0
Total Comments: 5
Location: Please Update

yesssssssssss

the gr8 article about the gr8 player to give a hard hitting slap on the critics of SACHIN

 
Yogesh Bhadauriya
Posted on: 2009-10-24 06:14:07
Rank: Loyal Sachinist
Total Topics: 14
Total Comments: 419
Location: Ahmedabad

Ponting wud never come close to Sachin..

Because he is not able to do. He is only do sledging

 
sabbir
Posted on: 2009-10-20 08:10:00
Rank: Newbie
Total Topics: 0
Total Comments: 2
Location: Please Update
great article....
 
pinaki
Posted on: 2009-10-16 22:54:37
Rank: Newbie
Total Topics: 0
Total Comments: 1
Location: Please Update
He is just beyond of comparision with any others ,as a batsman.He is his self competitor.
 
shyam
Posted on: 2009-10-03 08:02:07
Rank: Loyal Sachinist
Total Topics: 37
Total Comments: 524
Location: tirupati

to say this we dont want to see the statistcs at all

 

there is no comparison between them

 

if we compare it will be like comparing cat with a big cat(tiger) 

 
mohith
Posted on: 2009-10-03 00:14:17
Rank: Newbie
Total Topics: 0
Total Comments: 1
Location: Please Update
sachin is the greatest ever whom the cricketing world has witnessed.who the hell can be compared with him
 
ραvαn
Posted on: 2009-09-23 13:46:00
Rank: Loyal Sachinist
Total Topics: 57
Total Comments: 511
Location: Hyderabad
Sach is faarrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrr ahead of cheater
 
vishwambar
Posted on: 2009-09-09 09:30:05
Rank: Newbie
Total Topics: 0
Total Comments: 1
Location: Please Update

heyy sup god is god & no coparision betn god & others

 

 
Yogesh Zavare
Posted on: 2009-09-05 07:41:00
Rank: Newbie
Total Topics: 0
Total Comments: 1
Location: Please Update
defenitely  SACHIN the great!!!!!!!!
 
Unnikrishnan B
Posted on: 2009-08-29 06:22:19
Rank: Newbie
Total Topics: 0
Total Comments: 1
Location: Please Update
dont compare beginners with amateurs...
 
Darshan Dave
the answer is obvious...
Posted on: 2009-08-28 02:42:20
Rank: Sach Admirer
Total Topics: 11
Total Comments: 310
Location: Ahmedabad

Its MASTER who is far better then Punter.....

 

great article dude n great analysis.... this is jus d proof for those (incase if some1 needs) who thiks tat punter is better.....  Wink

 
Sunisha
Posted on: 2009-08-24 05:33:19
Rank: Newbie
Total Topics: 0
Total Comments: 1
Location: KERALA

EXCELLENT ARTICLE....HAPPY THAT I VE GOT SO MAY INFORMATIONS REGARDING THE LITTLE MASTREO....LOVE U SACHIN...PLAY FOR ANOTHER 18 YEARS...

 

 
yeshwanth
Posted on: 2009-08-24 04:20:25
Rank: Newbie
Total Topics: 0
Total Comments: 1
Location: tirupati
why to compare god with others
 
vamshi
Posted on: 2009-08-23 00:26:29
Rank: Newbie
Total Topics: 0
Total Comments: 1
Location: Please Update

Gr8 Facts dude.

I question, Is there any one who questions considering the above facts about his awesome and tremendous skills?

 

 

 

 
Sukhdeep
Posted on: 2009-08-18 14:03:31
Rank: Newbie
Total Topics: 0
Total Comments: 1
Location: Please Update
You can't compare the two... Sachin is God & the Aussie moron is not even a good human being !!
 
vignesh
Posted on: 2009-08-08 22:37:30
Rank: Newbie
Total Topics: 0
Total Comments: 1
Location: Please Update
ponting is notin but a mere squeler...he screws up himself and blames it on the crowd!!!!sachin is immortal..
 
nitin
Posted on: 2009-07-21 14:27:43
Rank: Newbie
Total Topics: 0
Total Comments: 1
Location: Please Update
Why compare god with mere mortals?
 
santhosh
Posted on: 2009-07-20 04:35:03
Rank: Newbie
Total Topics: 0
Total Comments: 1
Location: Please Update
sachin you are a really really true fighter for india .you have given your entire life for cricket thats really great. that has lead india a good name . afterall india should be proud that sachin has taken birth in this country.
 
anuj seth
Posted on: 2009-04-24 07:14:38
Rank: Newbie
Total Topics: 0
Total Comments: 1
Location: Please Update
ponting have no addicates how to play this gentle man game but u know very well how sachin is well mannerd
 
pramod
sachin
Posted on: 2009-04-10 00:00:53
Rank: Newbie
Total Topics: 0
Total Comments: 1
Location: Please Update
sachin sachin and only sachin
 
Mandar
Sachin is God...n Ponting is Beggar
Posted on: 2009-04-07 10:05:14
Rank: Newbie
Total Topics: 0
Total Comments: 1
Location: Please Update
Hey Punter..listen U will never catch me......now i am 5 ahead of u ..look...n catch me if u can...cos m sure u ll never....
 
DeepaK Mr. MaFia
Posted on: 2007-12-25 07:01:14
Rank: Absolute Sachinist
Total Topics: 95
Total Comments: 1773
Location: Deoria
@hassan i will suggest u onethin nothin said is better dan a nonsense so don't try to say anything ok
 
Harsh Mittal
@ hassan
Posted on: 2007-12-24 20:32:00
Rank: Regular Fan
Total Topics: 1
Total Comments: 3
Location: Please Update

Also u r saying inzi did well as an opener n scored 3 hundreds...then y wasn't he retained fr tht spot? also 12 odis doesn't prove anything.....had he done it for 200 odis then it would hv made sense! tendulkar has done it for 300 odd matches n still averages almost 45! dun think anyone can do tht!

 i'm not saying inzi was a bad batsman....he was a great batsman but tendulkar is on a dif level!

n whr hv u taken this discussion....it was comparing sachin to ponting.....nt sachin to inzamam! theres ntn to compare there!

 

 
Harsh Mittal
@ hassan
Posted on: 2007-12-24 20:26:17
Rank: Regular Fan
Total Topics: 1
Total Comments: 3
Location: Please Update

man as fr a 4th innings knock of his....i think u've forgotten the 137 in the chennai test of 1999 against pak. it wasn't a match winning knock but it was one of the best innings people ever saw n wasim akram who was the captain of the pakistan side acknowledged it!

 Also u r telling me that he averages 4 against wasim....think bfore u talk man....2003 wc he scored 98.....thts enough to get his average up beyond 4 isn't it?

he struggled against wasim, waqar and donald according to u but all three of them regard him as one of the best batsmen they have bowled to. I guess they r dumb......they shud hv come to u first rite n then given their opinion!

 
Anish
Posted on: 2007-12-24 15:39:24
Rank: Regular Fan
Total Topics: 0
Total Comments: 142
Location: Please Update

do we need comparing him to anyone???? we all know he is God. neways its a great work. i appreciate the hard work behind it.

@Hassan. stats dont tell u the perfect truth. with the above stats also its the same case. without these stats also anyone who has seen him playing wud have been able to tell that Sachin is better than Ponting. i have looked up the stats inn by inn & i know what i'm saying. how many times our bowlers have given our batsmen to chase 200-250? very rarely. neways, in the first test vs Pak this series, it was he who took us to victory. so shut ur mouth!!!!! SACHIN IS GOD

 
vineet
SACHIN is GOD..
Posted on: 2007-12-24 15:14:09
Rank: Newbie
Total Topics: 4
Total Comments: 7
Location: Please Update

kamaal kar ditta..

thandak pae gayee...

maza aa gaya bhai...tooo good.. awesome work 

less words and more Statistics.. 

now i wont speak ..i'll just forward this link to the people comparin SACHIN to ponting...

after all SACHIN is GOD... and pontin a mortal.. 

 
Hassaan
Posted on: 2007-12-24 06:30:22
Rank: Newbie
Total Topics: 0
Total Comments: 1
Location: Please Update

lol...ur comparing sachin's odi stats with inzi's...it seems u dont have a great understanding ov the game...inzi for the greater part ov his odi career played in the middle order and as we all noe one day cricket is a limited overs game inzi dint get to bat the same no. ov overs as sachin...take a look at inzi's stats in odis as an opener...in 12 odis he has scored 3 centuries...and his average as an opener is as gud as sachin's...on the other hand if u compare sachin's performance in the middle order wid inzi's performance, u will see tht inzi has done exceptionally well whereas sachin has struggled...

As far as sachin's performance in pressure situations is concerned, if u really wanna see how well he has done in pressure situation then take a look at his stats in the 4th innings ov a test match...not once has he played a match-winning knock for india in the 4th innings...NOT EVEN ONCE

 and u have been wrong in stating tht he scored big runs against wasim, waqar and donald...he struggled against these bowlers BIG TIME....he averages 4 against wasim akram[source:cricinfo]...big runs...lol

 
Anand Kumar
Posted on: 2007-12-24 03:54:17
Rank: Sach Admirer
Total Topics: 4
Total Comments: 38
Location: Please Update
what say guys?
 
Anand Kumar
Posted on: 2007-12-24 03:54:01
Rank: Sach Admirer
Total Topics: 4
Total Comments: 38
Location: Please Update

good one...no need to show any stats though....

Ponting wud never come close to Sachin...bcos he wud have to play against team like AUS to prove that Cool

 
nakul
Posted on: 2007-12-23 08:01:50
Rank: Newbie
Total Topics: 0
Total Comments: 2
Location: Please Update
sachin is god............
 
Duttnath
Posted on: 2007-12-23 01:48:04
Rank: Tendulkarized
Total Topics: 11
Total Comments: 346
Location: Durg, Chhattisgarh
WHY ARE WE COMPARING STATICALLY?WELL WHEN WE WILL SEE THERE ARE MANY P-EO-PLE WHO ARE HAVING MORE RUNS THAN SIR DONALD BRADMAN BUT ARE THEY GR8ER PLAYERS THAN HIM?I ONCE AGAIN SPEAK THAT STATS SHOW ONLY ONE FACE OF THE COIN.
 
srinivas
Posted on: 2007-12-23 00:22:20
Rank: Regular Fan
Total Topics: 1
Total Comments: 1
Location: Please Update
sachin is ultimate
 
Tejeswin Sharma
Posted on: 2007-12-22 18:44:16
Rank: Regular Fan
Total Topics: 1
Total Comments: 13
Location: Please Update

Really Really Really  Great work and statistical workCool

 
DeepaK Mr. MaFia
Posted on: 2007-12-22 07:47:31
Rank: Absolute Sachinist
Total Topics: 95
Total Comments: 1773
Location: Deoria
@ramakrishan no doubt about it dude
 
ramakrishna
Posted on: 2007-12-22 07:45:20
Rank: Newbie
Total Topics: 0
Total Comments: 1
Location: Please Update
really superb,this statistics shows how great batsman he is, really sachin is a legend
 
DeepaK Mr. MaFia
Posted on: 2007-12-22 02:23:35
Rank: Absolute Sachinist
Total Topics: 95
Total Comments: 1773
Location: Deoria
m really felt short of words 4 this article keep it up harsh u r really doin gr8 job
 
saurabh
Posted on: 2007-12-22 01:26:00
Rank: Regular Fan
Total Topics: 7
Total Comments: 53
Location: Jodhpur

ZABARDAST

SUPERB

EXCELLENT

TOO GOOD

FANTASTIC

WONDERFUL

WELL DONE HARSH !!!

 

HAIL SACHIN  SmileSmileSmileSmile

 
Chandu
Posted on: 2007-12-22 00:54:39
Rank: Tendulkarized
Total Topics: 14
Total Comments: 605
Location: Please Update
Great statistical analysis , harsh ur really a gr8 analyst
 
Sandeep
Posted on: 2007-12-22 00:54:22
Rank: Newbie
Total Topics: 0
Total Comments: 2
Location: Please Update
great article..just proves sachin is incomparableCool
 
Please login to comment